// you’re reading...

"Barefoot" Footwear

Review: Merrell Trail Glove



Merrell Trail Glove Shoe Review

By Al Gauthier

  ★★☆☆☆ 


Merrell has been making shoes for 30 years now. The most difficult part of writing reviews is when we have to write a review on a product that we have been excitedly anticipating only to find they fall short.  In the case of Merrell, the review process from beginning to end has been a very long one.  We originally confirmed the review of these shoes well before the public release date more than 6 months ago.  The pre-production models arrived and we put them through the review paces.  The results were less than ideal, however.  When we communicated our concerns to Merrell they were able to send production samples.  This whole process has taken many months.  Despite the long delay, we felt it was better to forgo the early review of the pre-production samples in order to give our readers an accurate review of a production product.

The difference between the pre-production samples and the productions samples turned out to be significant.  Here then is the review of the production version of the Men’s Merrell Trail Glove.

While the Trail Glove is a great attempt and a serious step forward for a minimalist shoe design for Merrell, it falls a little short of the mark.  Shoe companies like Merrell should have the resources to put out great product and do all the testing and prototyping necessary to refine a design before releasing a final product. We have left the days where minimalist shoes were new and unknown. In my view, these shoes are not yet ready for the public and, because Merrell is such a big company, I find myself far less tolerant of that fact.  Now lets get into the details.

Comfort
The shoe is soft and well-made on the inside.  The heel cup is thin, soft, and slightly padded.  The throat is low and slim, and together they make for a beautiful low profile fit for the heel.  The upper is well ventilated and the lacing system is nicely designed.  The inside of the shoe is a soft place without any ridges for a bare foot to live.  On this front they have done a great job.

The Merrell last seems to be based on the Vibram FiveFingers KSO Trek last, but with modifications. The toes have been pulled together and the shape of the toe box is round rather than foot-shaped.  The narrow outsole section between the heel and forefoot is very similar to the KSO Trek, but the materials used to form the arch of the outsole and the way in which the upper is designed have changed the way the shoe feels on the foot.  Overall, the effect is one that is too narrow.  While the length is certainly correct, a FiveFingers shoe would have more room for the toes to spread and would have no issues with width at all.  To be fair, there is a reasonable amount of toe room here for those with average feet.  The midfoot above the arch and going forward around the metatarsals is too narrow.  Walking and running, which cause the foot to widen with impact, make these shoes slightly uncomfortable.  The fault seems to lie not in the outsole itself, but in how it interfaces with the upper.  Despite the lacing system, the shoe doesn’t have the ability to adapt to different widths.  I suspect only the narrowest of feet would fit comfortable into these shoes.

Width
If different materials had been used, and some slight modifications made, I would suspect this shoe could be comfortable for those with wider feet.  I would expect the next version to be a very different shoe.  There is a reasonable but not generous amount of room in the toe box for the average foot.  Those with wide feet will not feel constricted toes but will likely be wanting for more room.

For a minimalist product marketed towards those that are familiar with a minimalist product, and thus may already have slightly widened feet, this is a curious design choice.

Sole
The sole of the Trail Glove is made of rubber compound TC-1. It is grippy and lightly lugged for off-road use.  It is very similar to the FiveFingers KSO Trek in its design but the outsole is far less flexible in its length and width compared to the FiveFingers KSO Trek.  The area containing the toes and the area directly behind the toes is the most flexible and is similar to the flexibility found in most minimalist shoes.  Overall the decreased flexibility decreases the ground transmission more than necessary, even for an off-road shoe.

While walking, there is a noticeable transition as the weight of the foot moves from the heel through to the toes to push off.  As the weight is transferred from the back of the foot over the ball of the foot there is the perception of rocking over an object.  It’s a difficult sensation to describe and one that we have not noticed in any other shoe.   This may be the result of feeling the transition from relatively inflexible to flexible.  Whatever the cause, it does not seem to have a purpose and is an unwelcome feeling.  Perhaps even more to the point, it is not at all like being barefoot and more like rocking the shoe over a hard object.

Flex
The sole has quite a bit of flexibility at the forefoot in the upwards direction. There is no flexibility in the heel and very little in the longitudinal or downwards directions. Therefore, although your foot is freely able to bend in the plantar direction, there is little ground feel around surface contours.  It is certainly significantly more flexible than the average consumer shoe, but for a true minimalist product it is a little bit too stiff my for preference – even in a trail running shoe.

Weight
These are not heavy shoes and in this way at least they fall well within the minimalist category.

 

 

Support / Insole
There is no arch support designed into the insole.  The inside of the shoe is reasonably flat. There is an upward angled sole area directly under the arch to protect the arch from stone bruising.  This same sole area is where I feel the design of the shoe has gone wrong.   Vibram FiveFingers did this well – it’s interesting indeed to see that this Vibram sole didn’t do such a great job.

There is no insole included in the shoe. There is 4 mm of compression molded EVA in the midsole for cushioning, which feels quite minimal while walking on hard surfaces.

Barefoot Feel
Because of the grip depth and reasonably poor flexibility overall, there is very little barefoot feel in this product.  It is understandably difficult to design a minimalist product used for trail running that also incorporates a feeling of “barefoot”.  Others have, however, been able to achieve this and so while difficult, it is possible.

Grip
The Trail Gloves have great grip. The TC-1 rubber is sticky enough for both natural and man-made surfaces. The toe grips provide added traction at the end of a walking or running stride.

Breathability
The microfiber air mesh upper is light and breathable. For an enclosed shoe, air circulation was better than average.

Quality of Materials / Manufacturing
Merrell’s experience in shoe making shines with the quality of construction.  We could find no fault or defects, no glue is visible, and there were no perceptible ridges on the inside of the shoe.  When a shoe is designed to be worn without socks, this is always of paramount importance and Merrell has done a beautiful job here.

Style
Despite all my complaining, I find these shoes some of the most attractive minimalist shoes on the market.  In particular, men’s shoes are so often needlessly bulky and ugly.  In stark contrast, these are sleek shoes with great lines.  For shoes in this category, they are very stylish.

Water Resistance
The mesh upper that allows so much air inside sadly does nothing to prevent water from entering the shoe.  The mesh is only a feature of the upper in 1/3 of the shoe and therefore wet surfaces and even shallow puddles shouldn’t cause any concern.

Sizing
The Trail Glove appears to run true to size for length, but will likely only be suitable for those with narrow feet.

Price
The Trail Gloves are listed on the Merrell website at $100 USD. Considering the quality of the materials and manufacturing, and their predicted durability, this is a reasonable price for the product if the mentioned issues we have found are not a problem for you.

Break-in Period
There is no break-in period required for the Trail Glove. The interior of the upper is quite comfortable right out of the box.  The materials used will not stretch over time and thus this shoe should be immediately comfortable.

Shoe care
The Merrell website says that the Trail Gloves can be washed as needed in cold water on a gentle cycle and air dried. This is a great feature for a shoe that is so comfortable to wear without socks.

Warmth
As the upper is made mostly of mesh, the Trail Gloves are not the warmest shoe. However, they can be worn with socks in cooler temperatures for added warmth. The narrow last may be an issue with thicker socks even if your bare feet feel comfortable in these shoes.

Uses
If you find the Trail Gloves are comfortable for you, they could be an excellent all-purpose casual, walking, running, trail running, or hiking shoe. If you’re looking for a minimalist shoe with a significant amount of ground feel, there are better options.




Summary
Merrell is awarded points for effort, but loses points overall in execution.  For a shoe marketed as the “Barefoot” line of shoes and for a shoe marketed as a minimalist product it falls short on several key points.  Flexibility is key in a minimalist shoe.  While protection is needed, especially in a shoe designed to withstand trail running, there is a fine line between too flexible and too rigid.  These are a little too inflexible in my view.  While the construction quality and aesthetic aspects of the Trail Glove satisfy, the issues with width, especially when considering the target market, let the Trail Glove down.  All but those with narrow feel may find these uncomfortable.  Perhaps even more importantly, those with narrow feet who continue to engage in minimalist activities may find their feet literally grow out of these shoes as the feet of many tend to widen with more time spent barefoot.

Why so harsh?  Because Merrell is a big company who I feel should have produced a product that fit a much wider audience.  Testing on a wide variety of foot types should have been part of the process but I suspect it wasn’t.  In the end, once the second round of shoes is released from Merrell I expect that subtle changes will make really significant improvements and a review done of these shoes next season may be entirely more positive.

To purchase these shoes, visit the Barefoot section of the Merrell website to purchase the Trail Gloves online or find your nearest Merrell retailer and inquire whether they sell the new Barefoot line.

Other Great Living Barefoot Articles:

Buy Vibram FiveFingers at these quality online retailers:

REI
Rock Creek
Half Moon Outfitters
The Flip Flopper

___________________________________________________________________________

About Living Barefoot Reviews:

As you read our reviews, please keep in mind that our reviewers review shoes in terms of their suitability for those looking to find the highest quality minimalist shoe products. All reviews are as factual as possible. In an effort to be transparent and ethical, we will point out any defects found, even if these do not affect the usability of the product. Not all defects will be present in final production shoes as we are sometimes offered “seconds” or pre-release products in an effort to provide you with reviews in a timely manor. In the event that serious issues are found with a review sample we will give every opportunity for the manufacturer to replace to explain the review samples before the final review is released. We never accept payments for reviews. We do not guarantee a good review for any products sent to us. We do not review products that do not claim to be minimalist or “barefoot like” unless we receive a significant number of requests from readers or listeners.

Should you have any questions about our review process or would like your product reviewed on our site, please do not hesitate to contact us using our contact page.

___________________________________________________________________________

Featured Interview: Christopher McDougall – Author of Born to Run

Listen HERE

Christopher McDougall is a well-spoken, humble man who has through the popularity of his book brought about some of the biggest changes in the perception of feet and running in recent years.  Join us in learning about how this talented author wrote his book, discovered his feet, and how he feels about barefooting and running.  This interview should not be missed.
We Talk about:
- Chris’s recent appearance at the TED Conference
- Thoughts on Interviews In General
- His first exposure to barefoot running
- How he came to find the Tarahumara while on assignment for the New York Times.
- He thoughts on his influence over barefoot running and ultra running
- How he struggled with writing Born to Run
- This thoughts on minimalist shoes
- And much more!
To learn more about Christopher McDougall visit his website: http://chrismcdougall.com

Buy His Book: Born to Run: A Hidden Tribe, Superathletes, and the Greatest Race the World Has Never Seen
Download the Audible Audiobook

Find “Living Barefoot” in iTunes and download it onto your iPod / iPhone or listen online

___________________________________________________________________________

Keep Yourself Connected:

Subscribe to our Twitter Feed, Listen to or download our Podcasts, subscribe to our RSS feed, or Subscribe to our email updates.

___________________________________________________________________________

Recent Minimalist Shoe Reviews:

Stay updated by being notified when we release a new reviews. Subscribe Here.

___________________________________________________________________________

Give us your support!

As Living Barefoot continues to grow our costs keep increasing.  In order to cover the many costs necessary to provide our readers and listeners with the great quality reviews and content on Living Barefoot we would like to request your help.

If you like what we are doing, we are asking for a tiny contribution to show your support. We guarantee you won’t notice the missing contribution, but if enough people participate, it can be a significant contribution to help continue to innovate and bring you great reviews, news, and personalities through the Living Barefoot Show.

What will we do in return?  We’ll continue to offer you great free news, reviews, and guest interviews on our show.  We will also decrease the amount of advertising on our site as subscriptions increase.

Donate as little as $1 monthly.  The subscription will simply deduct $1 from your bank or credit card monthly.  You can cancel the automatic withdrawal at any time.  You won’t notice $1, but we will!


Support Options




Discussion

14 comments for “Review: Merrell Trail Glove”

  1. I love the review. You really took the time to anazlyze each aspect of the shoe. Thank you for educating those who are not familiar with products so they can buy what fits them best, but I do need to say one constructive criticism…VFF’s are not perfect, in fact I can’t even wear them because the setup of my toes is weird, which means they are not the universal perfect barefoot shoe…don’t compare every product to a VFF because they have imperfections and it digs away at your argument and credibility. This is a review of a new product, not a comparison. And yes…I happen to like the Trail Glove.

    Posted by Will | June 1, 2011, 01:42
  2. Hi Will,

    Thank you for your comment! You are right, Fivefingers are not perfect. The reason for the comparison, which I should have made more clear now that I think about it, is that the outsole of the shoe is a Vibram outsole and has many similarities to the Fivefingers sole. The two companies have cooperated to produce this product so the comparison is needed. Those who know the Fivefingers product will wonder if the fit is the same. I was surprised how different the fit was.

    Fivefingers have a design that doesn’t allow for all foot types so your experience is understandable. Thanks for your comments.

    Posted by Al Gauthier | June 1, 2011, 06:46
  3. Thanks for the good review. I just purchased a pair of tough gloves after finding the trail gloves to tight as you noted. Hopefully because of the different materials used, the tough gloves will fit differently or stretch some. If not, they are mainly a work shoe for me, so no big deal.

    Posted by Grant | June 1, 2011, 16:07
  4. While I started off loving these after several weeks I ran into some significant issues. First, the darn things started coming apart! About midlength in the interior of the shoe is a black mesh-like lining that started coming detached. in one case just 32 days after purchase and in the other pair about 10 weeks after purchase. Unfortunately since it was outside the 30 day period all Merrell would do was exchange them for another pair.

    On top of that I think the darn thing is just too narrow in the mid-foot. I started experiencing pain about 4″ back from my small toe along the outside edge of my foot. The concerning thing is I do not have wide feet by any stretch of the imagination. It’s a shame, I really wanted to love these. Back to my VFF’s for now. keep up the great work guys!

    Posted by Chris Szumigala | June 13, 2011, 13:14
  5. Thanks for your detailed comment!

    Posted by Al Gauthier | June 13, 2011, 13:26
  6. I have switched to almost exclusively barefoot shoes – for work, running, hiking, etc. I have a pair of Trail Gloves and True Gloves. The Trail Gloves are great. I agree that they don’t feel “barefoot” but that is because you are not barefoot. I don’t have a real barefoot feel in my VFFs either.

    Overall, I strongly recommend the Trail Glove over the VFF. Much more comfortable and easier to put on. I also prefer the laces over the velcro.

    Posted by Chris | July 8, 2011, 02:22
  7. I’m sorry. I don’t agree at all. These are the best shoes I’ve ever worn. The toe box is great. I love the moccasin like feel, and I’ve worn them for over 400 miles hiking with 20 mile hikes being the norm.

    To each is own. But this is definitely not a 2 star product.

    Posted by bill | November 13, 2011, 15:44
  8. Hi Bill,
    I’m thrilled that you have written your comments. We are quite happy to hear that there are people who love these shoes. May I ask what other minimalist products you compared these with when you purchased? Also, tell us about your feet. Would you consider them narrow? It would be good to get a better idea of what foot type will find these comfortable.

    Posted by Al Gauthier | November 15, 2011, 06:57
  9. Funny thing is, yours is the only review I’ve seen that mentions the tight midfoot section on this shoe. I agree completely. What does it help that my toes can splay if my foot is squeezed? I tried them at the shop and my midfoot was sticking outside the sole on both sides, vulnerable to objects when trail running, uncomfortable under the foot.

    Pity since it seems like an amazing shoe otherwise…

    Posted by Allan | December 22, 2011, 13:08
  10. To be fair I am not a barefoot runner by any means. I mainly hike,discgolf, and mountain bike. Im 5’10″ 255lbs so lets go from there. These shoes fit perfectly and I am flat footed with major overpronation. From spring to fall I normally wear Keen Newport sandals for pretty much all my outdoor activities. I was very pleased with the toe box width and comfort of the Merrell Trail Glove. This review is obviously not for the true barefoot runner but I would recommend it for casual use and hiking. Yes I have tried other barefoot shoes, the Kigo Edge (horrible design) and the New Balance Minimus Trail (very narrow compared to the Merrell Trail).

    Posted by AG | April 6, 2012, 00:33
  11. Hi there and thank you for sharing your experience.

    It’s always interesting to hear different perspectives. The difficult comparison is that of perceived foot width. Feet come in so many shapes and sizes and one persons “wide” can be very different from another persons wide.

    As we have the rare position of comparison between most minimalist shoes and brands, ours is one based on comparison across the minimalist range combined with personal comfort observations based on our foot shape and what we know about feet in general.

    Our opinions are also from the perspective of those who are used to having considerable room in a shoe. We are far less tolerant of any constriction of discomfort when compared to the general public.

    We find it very frustrating when we review a product made by a big company were we feel they have missed the boat on a design aspect, so it’s great to hear your voices saying that you disagree with us as it may indicate that the average person may find these shoes quite acceptable.

    Posted by Al Gauthier | April 6, 2012, 08:13
  12. These shoes feel great on trails but not too great on roads. The grip on trails was exceptional. They are lightweight but have enough sole to glide over rocks. If you run roads with them they will wear fast tho. Didnt take significant mileage either but then again they are minimalist and designed for trails. But in one day they went from worn tread to nothing and I got blisters and swelling as a result of ignoring that. I think I may try the Saucony Hattori next

    Posted by M | May 19, 2012, 21:31
  13. Sounds like sour grapes from someone with wide feet. Two years later and many, many, thousands of satisfied customers have made this one of the most popular “minimalist” shoes on the market. Claims that they are only good for a small, narrow-footed market segment are clearly not standing up to the facts. Yes, the midfoot is snug, and people with particularly wide feet will probably be uncomfortable. There’s a wide version now, perhaps that might help. But overall, that snugness is best suited to keeping the shoe nice and firmly on the foot – unlike many of the competitors.

    Merrell traditionally fits narrower to medium feet with a medium to wider forefoot, though they do offer wide sizes on many models. The barefoot Trail Glove is consistent with their fit approach that has made them one of the most successfull footwear companies in the world, though certainly a major departure in functional design. So while these shoes are not a good fit for you, and a notable but small portion of wearers in general, they happen to fit a very sizable number of other people quite well.

    Lastly, their lack of flexibility disappears very quickly with use, though definitely a bit stiffer than some VFF models. But, they are a trail shoe, and designed to filter out some harshness – something that requires materials that are by nature not very flexible. It’s a tradeoff that many “barefoot” and minimalist ultra-runners have been very enthusiatic about.

    I hope you find your golden slipper – maybe the uber-wide and high volume vivobarefoot shoes will work well for you.

    Posted by Jason | April 16, 2013, 09:16
  14. Hi Jason. It appears that you likely work for Merrell, do you?

    I will admit that we are fans of wider shoes and Merrell in general, as you point out, tend to make lasts that are on the narrow side. Having said this we have a very good basis for comparison of minimalist shoes, having tested virtually every minimalist shoe on the market.

    Certainly if the shoe fits the wearer, and Merrell is the best fit, than they are a great option, but I imagine that many will find them a little too narrow, and constrictive in ways that are perhaps not ideal.

    We provide reviews based on our experiences and they are just that, our experiences. Unlike most blogs we do not review positively just to keep in the good graces of the companies who provide sample product for us. We review based on what we think of the product, and what we expect our readers will think. Sometimes that means that we make people unhappy, but we are here for the public, not for the marketing arms of distributors.

    Happy to have heard your comments. I honesty hope that most others agree with you and that we are wrong.

    Posted by Al Gauthier | May 5, 2013, 20:18

Post a comment

Recent Comments


Get Adobe Flash player